The Crime Writers’ Association

Whodunnit Dagger

The Whodunnit Dagger celebrates books where the sex, swearing, and bloodletting take place offstage–books that focus on the intellectual challenge at the heart of a good mystery, and which revolve around often quirky characters. Books in this category include cosy crime, traditional crime, and Golden Age-inspired mysteries.


Whodunnit Dagger 2026 Winner


Mel Pennant

A Murder for Miss Hortense

John Murray Press – Baskerville

Judges’ comments

A page-turning mystery that does something genuinely new with a classic whodunnit setup, and adds a flavour of the Windrush Generation experience. Miss Hortense is a smart, savvy, sassy addition to the pantheon of retired amateur detectives, and the community… More


2026 shortlist


2026 longlist

Author Title Publisher
Alexandra Benedict The Christmas Cracker Killer Simon & Schuster UK
SJ Bennett The Queen Who Came in from the Cold Bonnier Books UK
Anna Fitzgerald Healy Etiquette for Lovers & Killers Little, Brown Book Group
Victoria Goldman Little Secrets Three Crowns Publishing UK (self-published)
Robert Holtom A Queer Case Titan Books
Richard Hooton The Margaret Code Little, Brown Book Group
RL Killmore A Cinnamon Falls Mystery Simon & Schuster UK
Clare Mackintosh Other People’s Houses Little, Brown Book Group
Jo Middleton Not Another Bloody Christmas HarperCollins
Guy Morpuss A Trial in Three Acts Profile Books
Mel Pennant A Murder for Miss Hortense John Murray Press
CJ Wray Bad Influence Orion Fiction

The 2026 Judges

Gytha Lodge (Chair)

Gytha Lodge is the Sunday Times bestselling and Richard and Judy selected author of the Jonah Sheens series. A former playwright and content marketing manager, she’s now pretty happy with a situation where she mostly gets to read, write, listen in on people’s conversations in coffee shops, and mess around on her own social media. 

Steph Broadribb

Steph Broadribb is the author of the bestselling Retired Detectives Club series including Death in the Sunshine and the most recent book in the series Death on the Beach. She has also written the Lori Anderson bounty hunter series and the Starke/Bell police procedural novels (as Stephanie Marland). She has an MA in Creative Writing (Crime Fiction) and trained as a bounty hunter in California. Her books have been shortlisted for the eDunnit eBook of the year award, the ITW Best First Novel award, and the Dead Good Reader Awards.

Derek Farrell

is the author of five Danny Bird mystery novels as well as a novella and numerous short stories. He grew up in Dublin and now lives in West Sussex with what some people call “Way too many books.”

Tanya Kosinski

Raised on a diet of Secret Seven and Nancy Drew, Tanya developed her passion for crime fiction from an early age. You can only imagine the monumental impact being introduced to the works of Agatha Christie had on her. Tanya is based in the New Forest and is a bookseller for Waterstones. She gets a ridiculous amount of enjoyment when recommending murder mysteries to her customers. when she can bring herself out of reading Tanya needs to be reminded that she has a husband and two nearly adult children.

CWA Daggers

Sign-up for Daggers alerts

Want to know when the nominations open, be reminded of the deadlines or find out who the winners are?

Join the CWA

Become part of a thriving community of successful crime writers with invaluable support, expertise and marketing opportunities for all our members.


Advertise with us